A critical aspect of GST compliance is the GST appeals process, which allows taxpayers to challenge decisions made by GST authorities. Recent amendments, introduced through GST Notification 12/2024, have brought significant changes to the rules governing appeals and applications to the GST Appellate Tribunal. Specifically, these amendments affect Rules 110 and 111 and introduce a new Rule 113A. This article provides a detailed overview of these changes and their implications for taxpayers.

Understanding Rule 110: Appeal to the Appellate Tribunal

Rule 110 of the GST Rules has been substantially amended to clarify the procedure for filing an appeal with the Appellate Tribunal. Under the new provisions, an appeal under section 112(1) must be filed electronically using FORM GST APL-05, along with all relevant documents. Upon submission, a provisional acknowledgment is issued immediately, marking the official date of filing the appeal.

In cases where electronic filing is not feasible, the Registrar may allow manual filing through a special or general order. If manual filing is permitted, the appellant can submit the appeal in FORM GST APL-05, and a provisional acknowledgment will still be issued immediately.

A memorandum of cross-objections, if any, must also be filed electronically using FORM GST APL-06. Similar to the GST appeal process, the Registrar can allow manual submission if necessary.

The appeal and any memorandum of cross-objection must be signed as specified in Rule 26. A final acknowledgment, including the appeal number, is issued in FORM GST APL-02 once any defects are rectified. The date of the provisional acknowledgment is considered the official date of filing, which is essential for meeting statutory deadlines.

If the order appealed against is not uploaded on the common portal, the appellant must submit or upload a self-certified copy of the order within seven days. If submitted within this period, the provisional acknowledgment date is considered the filing date. If submitted after seven days, the final acknowledgment date becomes the official filing date.

Fee Structure

The fee for filing an appeal is ₹1,000 for every ₹1 lakh of tax or input tax credit involved, with a maximum fee of ₹25,000 and a minimum of ₹5,000. There is no fee for applications related to rectification of errors under section 112(10).

Rule 111: Application to the Appellate Tribunal

Amendments to Rule 111 further streamline the process of filing applications to the Appellate Tribunal under section 112(3). Like the appeal process in Rule 110, applications must be filed electronically using FORM GST APL-07, with a provisional acknowledgment issued immediately.

A memorandum of cross-objections to the Appellate Tribunal under sub-section (5) of section 112, if any, shall be filed electronically in FORM GST APL-06.

The provisions for manual filing are similar to those in Rule 110, where the Registrar may permit manual submissions through special or general orders. The process for issuing final acknowledgments also mirrors that in Rule 110, with the acknowledgment issued in FORM GST APL-02 after defects is rectified.

If the related order is not uploaded on the common portal, the appellant must submit or upload a self-certified copy within seven days. The timing determines whether the provisional acknowledgment date or the submission date of the self-certified copy will be the official filing date.

The role of the Registrar in this process is emphasized, with the term “Registrar” including the appointed Registrar, Joint Registrar, Deputy Registrar, and Assistant Registrar.

Introduction of Rule 113A: Withdrawal of Appeals or Applications

The newly introduced Rule 113A allows for the withdrawal of appeals or applications filed before the Appellate Tribunal. This rule provides taxpayers with the flexibility to withdraw their appeals or applications at any time before the Tribunal issues an order under section 113(1).

To withdraw, the appellant must file an application in FORM GST APL-05/07W. If a final acknowledgment in FORM GST APL-02 has already been issued, the withdrawal is subject to the Tribunal’s approval. The Tribunal must decide on the withdrawal application within fifteen days.

The rule also addresses the filing of fresh appeals or applications following a withdrawal. It mandates that any new appeal or application be filed within the time limits specified in section 112(1) or 112(3), ensuring taxpayers do not lose their opportunity to contest decisions if they withdraw and refile.

Conclusion

The amendments to Rules 110 and 111, along with the introduction of Rule 113A, represent significant developments in the GST appeals process. These changes aim to enhance the efficiency and transparency of the appeals process, providing clear guidelines for electronic and manual filings, acknowledgment procedures, and the withdrawal of appeals or applications.

For taxpayers and their advisors, understanding these amendments is crucial to navigating the GST appeals process effectively. As the GST system continues to evolve, staying informed about such changes will help ensure compliance and minimize the risks associated with procedural errors.

*****

If you are looking for an efficient Litigation Management Software, choose IRIS LMS!

What can you do with IRIS LMS?

1. Track: Status of Litigations on real-time basis at GSTIN Level
2. Store: Complete trail of Litigation from 1st Letter to Replies, Hearing Proceedings to Final Order
3. Retrieve: Data through friendly UI with custom categorizations
4. Archive: Gst Returns Data and Various Reconciliations to handle Departmental Audit in the future
5. Alerts: For various Due Dates for Pending Replies, Appeals, Personal Hearings, Written Submissions